QuickBooks vs Gusto: Choosing the Best Payroll Solution for Your Business

Small businesses now have efficient payroll solutions like Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll, eliminating the manual processes of the past. Gusto excels with its user-friendly platform, comprehensive HR features, and scalability, while QuickBooks Payroll seamlessly integrates with QuickBooks Online, ideal for those already in the QuickBooks ecosystem. This article compares both platforms to help you choose the best fit for your business needs.
Published on
December 10, 2024
connecting stripe to qbo woman looking at computer

The Evolution of Payroll Management

The world of payroll is evolving, and small businesses now have more options than ever when it comes to managing this critical function. Two of the most popular choices on the market today are Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll. Both platforms have revolutionized the way companies process payroll, but how do they differ, and which one is the best fit for your business?

In the past, payroll management involved time-consuming manual processes. Businesses relied heavily on paperwork, and errors were common due to human oversight. The emergence of digital payroll solutions has shifted this paradigm, making payroll management more accurate, efficient, and streamlined than ever before.

This article will examine the features, benefits, and limitations of Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll, helping small business owners like you make an informed decision. We'll explore everything from pricing plans to integration capabilities so you can choose the payroll platform that best meets your unique needs. 

Modern Payroll Solutions: A Game-Changer for Small Businesses

In the not-so-distant past, payroll processing was a tedious and time-consuming task, often involving mountains of paperwork and complex calculations. Small business owners had to dedicate significant time and resources to ensuring an accurate and timely payroll, taking their focus away from core business activities.

Advanced software automates repetitive tasks such as calculating deductions, filing taxes, and executing direct deposits, minimizing opportunities for error. Many solutions offer features that keep up with evolving tax laws and compliance requirements, so you stay up-to-date effortlessly.

Fortunately, the advent of innovative payroll platforms like Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll has transformed this landscape. These modern solutions automate payroll tasks, from tax filings to direct deposits, freeing up business owners to concentrate on strategic initiatives. No more tedious data entry or worrying about missing a tax deadline!

So, what sets these two platforms apart, and how can they empower your business? Let's take a closer look at each one's unique offerings.

Gusto: Simplifying Payroll with Comprehensive HR Features

connect stripe to quickbooks woman with laptop and dog

Gusto is a relatively new contender in the payroll space, but it has quickly made a name for itself with its user-friendly interface and efficient payroll processing. True to its name, Gusto brings a certain enthusiasm to the world of payroll, aiming to make the experience enjoyable for business owners and employees alike.

  • Simplicity at Its Finest: Gusto shines when it comes to simplicity and speed. Running payroll with Gusto is a breeze, taking as little as 11 minutes on average. Their intuitive platform guides users through each step of the process, making it accessible even for those who aren't payroll experts. This efficiency is a game-changer, especially for small business owners who wear multiple hats and value their time.
    To further enhance ease of use, Gusto provides a clean, straightforward dashboard that displays essential payroll information at a glance. Users can quickly review past payroll runs, make adjustments, and generate reports without having to navigate complicated menus or procedures.
  • HR Features Galore: One of Gusto's standout features is its comprehensive HR capabilities. It offers a wide range of benefits, including health, dental, vision, and even 529 college savings plans. Flexible spending accounts and commuter benefits are also part of the package. This extensive selection of benefits is a boon for businesses aiming to attract and retain top talent. Additionally, Gusto provides an HR resource center and dedicated support, ensuring you have the tools and guidance to navigate any HR challenge.
    More than just payroll, Gusto acts as an integrated HR platform, assisting with the onboarding process, facilitating employee surveys, and managing performance reviews, making it a versatile tool for evolving workplaces.
  • Scalability for Growth: Gusto is designed with scalability in mind. Whether you have a handful of employees or several hundred, Gusto can accommodate your business as it grows. Their pricing plans are structured accordingly, with a basic plan starting at $40/month plus $6/employee/month. This flexibility means you can start with Gusto when your business is small and scale up seamlessly as your team expands.
    Gusto also allows you to easily upgrade your service plan to match your growing needs, ensuring access to a broader range of features and benefits management options as your company evolves.
  • Seamless Integrations: One of Gusto's strengths is its ability to integrate with a diverse range of third-party software. From accounting platforms to time-tracking tools and HR management systems, Gusto plays well with others. This interoperability ensures that your payroll data flows smoothly between different systems, reducing manual data entry and potential errors.
    If you’re using software like Slack, QuickBooks, or Asana, you can rest assured that Gusto will make the integration process seamless and efficient, saving you from modifying existing systems or workflows.
  • Support When You Need It: Gusto offers robust support options, including an extensive help center with articles and tutorials. If you need more personalized assistance, their customer support team is just a message away. With Gusto, you're never left alone to navigate the complexities of payroll and HR.
    Users can also join the Gusto community forums to exchange tips and best practices with fellow users, providing additional learning opportunities outside of official support channels.

QuickBooks Payroll: Leveraging the Power of the QuickBooks Ecosystem

connecting stripe to quickbooks man sitting by laptop with coffee

QuickBooks Payroll, on the other hand, is a powerhouse in the world of accounting and financial management. As a product of Intuit, the same company behind QuickBooks Online, it has strong roots in the financial software space. This heritage gives QuickBooks Payroll a unique advantage for businesses already using QuickBooks for their accounting needs.

  • Seamless Integration within the QuickBooks Ecosystem: One of the biggest selling points of QuickBooks Payroll is its seamless integration with other Intuit products, particularly QuickBooks Online. If you're already using QuickBooks for accounting, adding QuickBooks Payroll can create a cohesive ecosystem. Your financial data will flow effortlessly between the two systems, reducing the need for manual data transfer. This integration also ensures that your payroll expenses are accurately reflected in your accounting records.
    This level of integration allows for automated error checking and seamless import of employee data, payroll updates, and financial statistics, which helps maintain accuracy throughout financial reports.
  • Faster Direct Deposit Options: QuickBooks Payroll offers faster direct deposit options compared to Gusto. With same-day direct deposit available in higher tiers, you can pay your employees faster, which is a significant advantage in today's fast-paced business environment. Employees appreciate timely payments, and QuickBooks Payroll delivers on that front.
    QuickBooks Payroll also provides customizable pay schedules, allowing businesses to choose a frequency that aligns with cash flow needs and employee preferences, providing greater financial flexibility.
  • Ideal for Smaller Businesses: QuickBooks Payroll is optimized for smaller businesses, particularly those with 50 employees or less. Its pricing plans reflect this focus, starting at $45/month plus $5/employee/month. This makes it an affordable option for startups and small businesses that may not require the extensive features of Gusto just yet.
    Additionally, for new small businesses, the quick setup wizard simplifies the onboarding process, making it easy to get up and running without needing extensive technical experience.
  • Health Benefits Coverage: While Gusto offers a broader range of benefits, QuickBooks Payroll holds its own by providing health benefits in 48 states. This is a crucial advantage, as health insurance is a top priority for many employees. QuickBooks Payroll ensures that small businesses can offer competitive health coverage to their staff, enhancing their appeal as employers.
    With the ability to choose from multiple providers, QuickBooks Payroll allows businesses to tailor benefits packages to meet the specific needs and preferences of their workforce.
  • HR Support and Resources: QuickBooks Payroll also provides HR support, including an HR support center and, in its Elite plan, a personal HR advisor. This feature gives small business owners access to expert guidance on HR matters, helping them navigate complex employment laws and best practices.
    QuickBooks' HR support features include document templates, in-depth articles on legal compliance, and even webinars for ongoing HR education.

Acodei: Enhancing Your QuickBooks Experience

connect stripe to quickbooks woman smiling at laptop

Here at Acodei, we understand that choosing the right payroll platform is just the beginning. Implementing and optimizing that platform to suit your unique business needs is where the real magic happens. This is why we specialize in uniting Stripe and QuickBooks for powerful business solutions

Our team of experts can help you integrate Stripe and QuickBooks in an automated sync. By bridging Stripe and QuickBooks, we offer a streamlined and effective solution to businesses everywhere. The joint force of these two giants save tons of bookkeeping hours for QuickBooks Accountants and small business owners alike.

With Acodei by your side, you can focus on what you do best—growing your business—while we handle the technical details.

Our commitment to providing personalized solutions means we’re always exploring new ways to enhance system capabilities, from adding custom features to developing unique workflows that align with your business processes.

Making the Right Choice for Your Payroll Needs

Both Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll are exceptional platforms, each with its unique advantages. Gusto stands out for its user-friendliness, comprehensive HR features, and broad integration capabilities, making it a versatile choice for growing businesses. On the other hand, QuickBooks Payroll shines within the QuickBooks ecosystem, offering seamless integration with QuickBooks Online and faster direct deposit options.

When deciding between the two, consider your business's specific needs and existing software ecosystem. If you're already invested in the QuickBooks world, QuickBooks Payroll may be the natural choice. However, if you require more extensive HR capabilities and plan to scale beyond 50 employees, Gusto could be the better long-term partner.

Some factors to consider include the level of HR support you require, the size of your organization, and how crucial it is for your payroll platform to integrate with existing systems like QuickBooks Online. You might also assess whether advanced features such as employee feedback or performance review tools are critical for your business goals.

Ultimately, the "right" choice depends on your unique circumstances. As your business evolves, your payroll needs may change, and that's okay! The beauty of modern payroll platforms is their adaptability, allowing them to grow with your business. So, embrace the future of payroll, and take your pick between these two outstanding options.

To learn more about how Acodei can assist with QuickBooks setup, integration, and optimization, visit our website at http://www.acodei.com. Our team is dedicated to helping small businesses like yours.

Get the latest blog posts
No spam. Just the latest updates and tips, on everything related to Stripe, QuickBooks and automating them.
Read about our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Give Acodei a shot
Start automating your Stripe QuickBooks workflow with Acodei. See the demo, or get started right away.